snp
See this word as a collocate cloud
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | committee members rhoda grant highlands |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| falkirk west cunningham roseanna perth | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ewing fergus inverness east nairn |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing margaret anne moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ewing mrs margaret moray snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ferguson patricia glasgow maryhill lab |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | i agree with that convener |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | i am grateful to the |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | i would like an action |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ian jenkins tweeddale ettrick and |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | maureen macmillan highlands and islands |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | mr jamie mcgrigor highlands and |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | paragraph 7 of the written |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | politicians are often in receipt |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | ross finnie west of scotland |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | trish godman west renfrewshire lab |
| inverness east nairn and lochaber | snp | will the minister give way |
| 17 36 fiona hyslop lothians | snp | almost 10 years ago to |
| lab ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | angus mackay edinburgh south lab |
| jim wallace fiona hyslop lothians | snp | ben wallace north east scotland |
| possible ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | can the minister give an |
| alex salmond banff and buchan | snp | david mcletchie lothians con mr |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | david mcletchie lothians con the |
| convener ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | deputy convener ian jenkins tweeddale |
| convener mr kenny macaskill lothians | snp | deputy convener ian jenkins tweeddale |
| union ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | does the member agree that |
| falkirk west cunningham roseanna perth | snp | douglas hamilton lord james lothians |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | douglas hamilton lord james lothians |
| lab mr kenny macaskill lothians | snp | dr elaine murray dumfries lab |
| govan lab fiona hyslop lothians | snp | dr sylvia jackson stirling lab |
| ld ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | george lyon argyll and bute |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harper robin lothians green hyslop |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harper robin lothians green hyslop |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harper robin lothians green hyslop |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harper robin lothians green hyslop |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harper robin lothians green hyslop |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harper robin lothians green hyslop |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harper robin lothians grn hyslop |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | hyslop fiona lothians snp ingram |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | hyslop fiona lothians snp ingram |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | hyslop fiona lothians snp ingram |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | hyslop fiona lothians snp ingram |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | hyslop fiona lothians snp ingram |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | hyslop fiona lothians snp ingram |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hyslop fiona lothians snp ingram |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | hyslop fiona lothians snp ingram |
| now ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | i am interested in the |
| margo ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | i apologise for being late |
| lab hyslop fiona jane lothians | snp | i ingram adam hamilton south |
| to take fiona hyslop lothians | snp | i know some of the |
| 03 ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | i promise to be right |
| 10 mr kenny macaskill lothians | snp | i want to deal with |
| be one fiona hyslop lothians | snp | i was brought up in |
| 15 46 fiona hyslop lothians | snp | i will move amendment s1m |
| islands snp hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| fife con hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| lothians green hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| lothians green hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| fife con hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| islands snp hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| islands snp hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| lothians green hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| lothians green hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| rutherglen lab hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| islands snp hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| fife con hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| lothians green hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| lothians green hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| lothians green hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| lothians grn hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| islands snp hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| fife con hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| islands snp hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| lothians green hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| scotland snp hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| islands snp hyslop fiona lothians | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| henry michael matheson central scotland | snp | lord james douglas hamilton lothians |
| committee substitutes roseanna cunningham perth | snp | lord james douglas hamilton lothians |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | macaskill mr kenny lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald margo lothians ind marwick |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | macdonald ms margo lothians snp |
| lab macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | macintosh mr kenneth eastwood lab |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macaskill mr kenny lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| snp macdonald ms margo lothians | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| lab ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | maureen macmillan highlands and islands |
| lab macaskill kenneth wright lothians | snp | mcaveety francis glasgow shettleston lab |
| central lab macdonald margo lothians | snp | mcgrigor james angus roderick neil |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | mcletchie david lothians con monteith |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | mcletchie david lothians con monteith |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | mcletchie david lothians con monteith |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | mcletchie david lothians con monteith |
| fiona grace west of scotland | snp | mcletchie david william lothians con |
| lab mr kenny macaskill lothians | snp | mr brian monteith mid scotland |
| ld ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | mr duncan mcneil greenock and |
| ld mr kenny macaskill lothians | snp | mr john home robertson east |
| lab mr kenny macaskill lothians | snp | mr kenneth macintosh eastwood lab |
| ld mr kenny macaskill lothians | snp | mr kenneth macintosh eastwood lab |
| snp ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | mrs mary mulligan linlithgow lab |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | ms margo macdonald lothians snp |
| judges ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | my area of interest impacts |
| time ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | on a point of order |
| mccabe ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | on a point of order |
| to ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | on a point of order |
| scotland ld fiona hyslop lothians | snp | paul martin glasgow springburn lab |
| 33 mr kenny macaskill lothians | snp | quoting selectively from history is |
| crawford mid scotland and fife | snp | robin harper lothians green angus |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | sir david steel lothians ld |
| reid mid scotland and fife | snp | stood sir david steel lothians |
| gordon ld fiona hyslop lothians | snp | the deputy minister for health |
| welcome mr kenny macaskill lothians | snp | the minister will be aware |
| the matter fiona hyslop lothians | snp | this is the second time |
| 9 ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| system ms margo macdonald lothians | snp | will the member give way |
| fashion mrs margaret ewing moray | snp | does the minister agree that |
| lab mrs margaret ewing moray | snp | euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| snp ewing margaret anne moray | snp | ewing winifred margaret highlands and |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp ewing mrs margaret moray | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| exceeded mrs margaret ewing moray | snp | i am interested in the |
| 27 mrs margaret ewing moray | snp | i recognise that we are |
| snp mr kenneth gibson glasgow | snp | mrs margaret ewing moray snp |
| debate mrs margaret ewing moray | snp | the member spoke about the |
| snp mrs margaret ewing moray | snp | trish godman west renfrewshire lab |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | andrew wilson central scotland snp |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | it is my pleasure to |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | karen whitefield airdrie and shotts |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | modernising government as an amendment |
| ld ms sandra white glasgow | snp | mr john swinney north tayside |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | on a point of order |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | on a point of order |
| ross ld sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney john ramsay north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| glasgow ssp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| scotland snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| glasgow ssp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| glasgow ssp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| glasgow ssp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| glasgow ssp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| glasgow ssp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| buchan snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| glasgow ssp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| scotland snp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| glasgow ssp sturgeon nicola glasgow | snp | swinney mr john north tayside |
| swinney john ramsay north tayside | snp | t thomson elaine margaret aberdeen |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | the secretary of state for |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | to ask the first minister |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | to ask the first minister |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | to ask the first minister |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | to ask the first minister |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | tosh mr murray south of |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | tosh mr murray south of |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | tosh mr murray south of |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | tosh mr murray south of |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | tosh mr murray south of |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | ullrich kay west of scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | wallace ben north east scotland |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| swinney mr john north tayside | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| mr john swinney north tayside | snp | will the member give way |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | abstentions gallie phil south of |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | abstentions gallie phil south of |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | abstentions gallie phil south of |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | abstentions gallie phil south of |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | abstentions gallie phil south of |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | abstentions gallie phil south of |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | abstentions gallie phil south of |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | abstentions reid mr george mid |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | abstentions reid mr george mid |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | against aitken bill glasgow con |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | against aitken bill glasgow con |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | against aitken bill glasgow con |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | against alexander ms wendy paisley |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | against baillie jackie dumbarton lab |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | against barrie scott dunfermline west |
| 12 linda fabiani central scotland | snp | all i can say is |
| 43 michael matheson central scotland | snp | as a member of the |
| lab michael matheson central scotland | snp | attended acting clerk to the |
| lab andrew wilson central scotland | snp | attended the following also attended |
| ld andrew wilson central scotland | snp | attended the following also attended |
| snp andrew wilson central scotland | snp | attended witnesses mr jack mcconnell |
| ld andrew wilson central scotland | snp | attended witnesses muir russell permanent |
| henry michael matheson central scotland | snp | bill aitken glasgow con george |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | cathy peattie falkirk east lab |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | cathy peattie falkirk east lab |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | clerk to the committee steve |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | committee substitutes phil gallie south |
| convener alex neil central scotland | snp | deputy convener miss annabel goldie |
| convener alex neil central scotland | snp | deputy convener miss annabel goldie |
| character andrew wilson central scotland | snp | does the first minister agree |
| earlier linda fabiani central scotland | snp | does the member accept that |
| con ms sandra white glasgow | snp | donald gorrie central scotland ld |
| ld alex neil central scotland | snp | donald gorrie central scotland ld |
| lab alex neil central scotland | snp | donald gorrie central scotland ld |
| lab michael matheson central scotland | snp | euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire |
| winifred margaret highlands and islands | snp | f fabiani linda central scotland |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | fabiani linda central scotland snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | ferguson patricia glasgow maryhill lab |
| f fabiani linda central scotland | snp | ferguson patricia josephine glasgow maryhill |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | fergusson alex south of scotland |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | fergusson alex south of scotland |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | fergusson alex south of scotland |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | fergusson alex south of scotland |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | fergusson alex south of scotland |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | fraser murdo mid scotland and |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gallie phil south of scotland |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| snp fabiani linda central scotland | snp | gibson mr kenneth glasgow snp |
| amicus andrew wilson central scotland | snp | i am mildly frustrated by |
| 20 michael matheson central scotland | snp | i congratulate my colleague fergus |
| 30 alex neil central scotland | snp | i follow on from what |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | i inform members of the |
| 45 linda fabiani central scotland | snp | i say to annabel goldie |
| 00 michael matheson central scotland | snp | i take on board the |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | i take the same view |
| 47 linda fabiani central scotland | snp | i was going to congratulate |
| soon alex neil central scotland | snp | i welcome the minister s |
| made andrew wilson central scotland | snp | i welcome the new minister |
| 57 linda fabiani central scotland | snp | i wish to speak on |
| period michael matheson central scotland | snp | i would like some clarification |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | is it not a sad |
| agreement andrew wilson central scotland | snp | is it possible for us |
| curran linda fabiani central scotland | snp | john scott ayr con nora |
| lab andrew wilson central scotland | snp | john young west of scotland |
| lab alex neil central scotland | snp | john young west of scotland |
| con michael matheson central scotland | snp | karen whitefield airdrie and shotts |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | l will come in after |
| else michael matheson central scotland | snp | like donald gorrie i was |
| 24 alex neil central scotland | snp | like many other members i |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | malcolm chisholm edinburgh north and |
| con alex neil central scotland | snp | mary scanlon highlands and islands |
| lab michael matheson central scotland | snp | mary scanlon highlands and islands |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael central scotland snp |
| tricia mid scotland and fife | snp | matheson michael stephen central scotland |
| lab matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcallion mr john dundee east |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgrigor mr jamie highlands and |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgrigor mr jamie highlands and |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgrigor mr jamie highlands and |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgrigor mr jamie highlands and |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgrigor mr jamie highlands and |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgrigor mr jamie highlands and |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgrigor mr jamie highlands and |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| snp matheson michael central scotland | snp | mcgugan irene north east scotland |
| mcgugan irene north east scotland | snp | mcintosh mrs lyndsay central scotland |
| mcgugan irene north east scotland | snp | mcintosh mrs lyndsay central scotland |
| mcgugan irene north east scotland | snp | mcintosh mrs lyndsay central scotland |
| mcgugan irene north east scotland | snp | mcintosh mrs lyndsay central scotland |
| mcgugan irene north east scotland | snp | mcintosh mrs lyndsay central scotland |
| mcgugan irene north east scotland | snp | mcintosh mrs lyndsay central scotland |
| mcgugan irene north east scotland | snp | mcleish henry central fife lab |
| 19 alex neil central scotland | snp | members of all parties have |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | michael russell south of scotland |
| matheson michael stephen central scotland | snp | monteith brian mid scotland and |
| mackay andrew wilson central scotland | snp | mr david davidson north east |
| lab linda fabiani central scotland | snp | mr kenneth gibson glasgow snp |
| lab linda fabiani central scotland | snp | mr michael mcmahon hamilton north |
| lab alex neil central scotland | snp | mr mike rumbles west aberdeenshire |
| lab michael matheson central scotland | snp | mr tom mccabe hamilton south |
| wallace michael matheson central scotland | snp | mrs lyndsay mcintosh central scotland |
| baillie mr kenneth gibson glasgow | snp | mrs lyndsay mcintosh central scotland |
| lab linda fabiani central scotland | snp | mrs lyndsay mcintosh central scotland |
| lab linda fabiani central scotland | snp | mrs lyndsay mcintosh central scotland |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | mrs lyndsay mcintosh central scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | neil alex central scotland snp |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | neil alex central scotland snp |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | neil alex central scotland snp |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | neil alex central scotland snp |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | neil alex central scotland snp |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | neil alex central scotland snp |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | neil alex central scotland snp |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | neil alex central scotland snp |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | neil alex central scotland snp |
| n neil alexander central scotland | snp | o oldfather irene cunninghame south |
| wishes alex neil central scotland | snp | on a point of order |
| 58 alex neil central scotland | snp | on a point of order |
| snp neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| snp neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| snp neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| con neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| snp neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| con neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| snp neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| con neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| con neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| con neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| snp neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| con neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| snp neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| snp neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| snp neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| con neil alex central scotland | snp | paterson mr gil central scotland |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | peacock peter highlands and islands |
| paterson gil martin central scotland | snp | peacock peter james highlands and |
| 1 linda fabiani central scotland | snp | performance of holyrood progress group |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| paterson mr gil central scotland | snp | quinan mr lloyd west of |
| fiona mcleod west of scotland | snp | rose mr gil paterson central |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | rose sarah boyack members will |
| brian adam north east scotland | snp | sarah boyack edinburgh central lab |
| richard lochhead north east scotland | snp | sarah boyack edinburgh central lab |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | sarah boyack edinburgh central lab |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | sarah boyack edinburgh central lab |
| 33 alex neil central scotland | snp | thank you presiding officer for |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | the changes seem to be |
| con linda fabiani central scotland | snp | the deputy minister for enterprise |
| con linda fabiani central scotland | snp | the deputy minister for social |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | the deputy presiding officer the |
| 09 michael matheson central scotland | snp | the minister will be well |
| mr gil paterson central scotland | snp | the only interest i think |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | the presiding officer the result |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | the presiding officer the result |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | the presiding officer the result |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | the presiding officer the result |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | the presiding officer the result |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | the presiding officer the result |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | the presiding officer the result |
| 41 andrew wilson central scotland | snp | the snp will not obstruct |
| 4 andrew wilson central scotland | snp | to ask the first minister |
| 5 alex neil central scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| 2 michael matheson central scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| 5 michael matheson central scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| 5 alex neil central scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| 7403 alex neil central scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| 48 michael matheson central scotland | snp | we have already been asked |
| divides linda fabiani central scotland | snp | when we took evidence from |
| wilson central scotland snp the | snp | will not obstruct the course |
| state alex neil central scotland | snp | will the member give way |
| rose alex neil central scotland | snp | will the minister give way |
| scotland andrew wilson central scotland | snp | will the minister give way |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| con welsh mr andrew angus | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| con welsh mr andrew angus | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | wilson andrew central scotland snp |
| wilson andrew john central scotland | snp | y young john henderson west |
| 37 linda fabiani central scotland | snp | you caught me on the |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | young john west of scotland |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | young john west of scotland |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | young john west of scotland |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | young john west of scotland |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | young john west of scotland |
| snp wilson andrew central scotland | snp | young john west of scotland |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| stevenson stewart banff and buchan | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | committee members lord james douglas |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | committee substitutes murdo fraser mid |
| campbell colin west of scotland | snp | crawford bruce mid scotland and |
| campbell colin west of scotland | snp | crawford bruce mid scotland and |
| campbell colin west of scotland | snp | crawford bruce mid scotland and |
| campbell colin west of scotland | snp | crawford bruce mid scotland and |
| campbell colin west of scotland | snp | crawford bruce mid scotland and |
| campbell colin west of scotland | snp | crawford bruce mid scotland and |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp curran |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp davidson |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp davidson |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp davidson |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp douglas |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp elder |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp elder |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp elder |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp elder |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp elder |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp ewing |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp ewing |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp ewing |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp ewing |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp ewing |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp ewing |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp fabiani |
| bruce mid scotland and fife | snp | curran ms margaret glasgow baillieston |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | dr richard simpson ochil lab |
| crawford mid scotland and fife | snp | dr winnie ewing highlands and |
| duncan graeme highlands and islands | snp | harding keith mid scotland and |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harding mr keith mid scotland |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harding mr keith mid scotland |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harding mr keith mid scotland |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harding mr keith mid scotland |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harding mr keith mid scotland |
| mr duncan highlands and islands | snp | harding mr keith mid scotland |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | helen eadie dunfermline east lab |
| crawford mid scotland and fife | snp | i am interested in the |
| reid mid scotland and fife | snp | i congratulate sir david i |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | i understand the convener s |
| reid mid scotland and fife | snp | i want to pay tribute |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | i welcome the report from |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | i welcome the scottish charity |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | iain smith north east fife |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | it would be an excellent |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | johnston nick mid scotland and |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | johnston nick mid scotland and |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | johnston nick mid scotland and |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | johnston nick mid scotland and |
| lochhead richard north east scotland | snp | marwick tricia mid scotland and |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | miss annabel goldie west of |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | monteith mr brian mid scotland |
| fiona mcleod west of scotland | snp | mr brian monteith mid scotland |
| irene mcgugan north east scotland | snp | mr brian monteith mid scotland |
| reid mid scotland and fife | snp | mr david davidson north east |
| reid mid scotland and fife | snp | mr jamie mcgrigor highlands and |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | mr keith harding mid scotland |
| lab mr kenneth gibson glasgow | snp | mr keith harding mid scotland |
| curran mr kenneth gibson glasgow | snp | mr keith harding mid scotland |
| lloyd quinan west of scotland | snp | mr keith raffan mid scotland |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | mr michael mcmahon hamilton north |
| reid mid scotland and fife | snp | mrs mary mulligan linlithgow lab |
| crawford mid scotland and fife | snp | my question is for angus |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | nick johnston mid scotland and |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | nora radcliffe gordon ld des |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | on a point of order |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | on a point of order |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | patricia ferguson glasgow maryhill lab |
| mr lloyd west of scotland | snp | reid mr george mid scotland |
| mr lloyd west of scotland | snp | reid mr george mid scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | reid mr george mid scotland |
| mr lloyd west of scotland | snp | reid mr george mid scotland |
| mr lloyd west of scotland | snp | reid mr george mid scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | reid mr george mid scotland |
| mr lloyd west of scotland | snp | reid mr george mid scotland |
| mr lloyd west of scotland | snp | reid mr george mid scotland |
| mr lloyd west of scotland | snp | reid mr george mid scotland |
| mr lloyd west of scotland | snp | reid mr george mid scotland |
| newlands mid scotland and fife | snp | robison shona north east scotland |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | robison shona north east scotland |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | robison shona north east scotland |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | robison shona north east scotland |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | robison shona north east scotland |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | robison shona north east scotland |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | robison shona north east scotland |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| reid mid scotland and fife | snp | stood john young west of |
| crawford mid scotland and fife | snp | susan deacon edinburgh east and |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | the committee decided that there |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | the debate allows members to |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | the deputy presiding officer the |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | the deputy presiding officer the |
| george mid scotland and fife | snp | the deputy presiding officer the |
| crawford mid scotland and fife | snp | the feeling of the parliament |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | the first minister will confirm |
| crawford mid scotland and fife | snp | the minister for transport sarah |
| crawford mid scotland and fife | snp | the purpose of the snp |
| marwick mid scotland and fife | snp | towards the end of the |
| crawford mid scotland and fife | snp | will the minister help me |
| reid mid scotland and fife | snp | госпожа президент спасибо большое дорогие |
| elder dorothy grace douglas glasgow | snp | ewing fergus stewart inverness east |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | against aitken bill glasgow con |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | against aitken bill glasgow con |
| scotland snp we on the | snp | benches offer no opposition to |
| snp s financial management the | snp | cannot even manage its own |
| campbell colin west of scotland | snp | cunningham roseanna perth snp davidson |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | curran margaret patricia glasgow baillieston |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | davidson mr david north east |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | davidson mr david north east |
| scotland snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | davidson mr david north east |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | davidson mr david north east |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | elder dorothy grace glasgow snp |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | elder dorothy grace glasgow snp |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | elder dorothy grace glasgow snp |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | elder dorothy grace glasgow snp |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | elder dorothy grace glasgow snp |
| snp elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| snp elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| snp elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| snp elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| snp elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| fife snp cunningham roseanna perth | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| snp gibson mr kenneth glasgow | snp | ingram mr adam south of |
| snp the purpose of the | snp | motion today is simple and |
| just how inadequate is the | snp | s financial management the snp |
| 42 mr kenneth gibson glasgow | snp | the snp warmly welcomes the |
| kenneth gibson glasgow snp the | snp | warmly welcomes the bill this |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | we on the snp benches |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| con welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| lab welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| con welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| con welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| ullrich kay west of scotland | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| con welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| snp welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| con welsh mr andrew angus | snp | white ms sandra glasgow snp |
| snp white ms sandra glasgow | snp | whitefield karen airdrie and shotts |
| stewart stevenson banff and buchan | snp | committee substitutes roseanna cunningham perth |
| 1890 1 roseanna cunningham perth | snp | crime as an amendment to |
| 1 convener roseanna cunningham perth | snp | deputy convener gordon jackson glasgow |
| falkirk west cunningham roseanna perth | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| falkirk west cunningham roseanna perth | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| ld against cunningham roseanna perth | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| ld against cunningham roseanna perth | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| ld against cunningham roseanna perth | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| ld against cunningham roseanna perth | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| ld against cunningham roseanna perth | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| ld against cunningham roseanna perth | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| division for cunningham roseanna perth | snp | grahame christine south of scotland |
| dumbarton lab roseanna cunningham perth | snp | i assert that my primary |
| solemn affirmation roseanna cunningham perth | snp | the following members took the |
| alex salmond banff and buchan | snp | agriculture and rural affairs that |
| stewart stevenson banff and buchan | snp | by you peter peacock not |
| stewart stevenson banff and buchan | snp | cathy peattie falkirk east lab |
| stewart stevenson banff and buchan | snp | committee substitutes george lyon argyll |
| stewart stevenson banff and buchan | snp | forgive me robin but i |
| stewart stevenson banff and buchan | snp | i am happy to come |
| stewart stevenson banff and buchan | snp | i listened carefully to what |
| stewart stevenson banff and buchan | snp | nora radcliffe gordon ld fiona |
| alex salmond banff and buchan | snp | of course we welcome the |
| elliot anderson banff and buchan | snp | scanlon mary elizabeth highlands and |
| alex salmond banff and buchan | snp | scottish executive s compact with |
| mr alex banff and buchan | snp | sheridan tommy glasgow ssp sturgeon |
| mr alex banff and buchan | snp | sheridan tommy glasgow ssp sturgeon |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | stevenson stewart banff and buchan |
| robison shona north east scotland | snp | stevenson stewart banff and buchan |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | stevenson stewart banff and buchan |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | stevenson stewart banff and buchan |
| alex salmond banff and buchan | snp | the scottish national party parliamentary |
| stewart stevenson banff and buchan | snp | there is clearly a wide |
| alex salmond banff and buchan | snp | to ask the first minister |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | a matter that concerned everyone |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | abstentions adam brian north east |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | as cathy peattie said language |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | ben wallace north east scotland |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | bill aitken glasgow con ms |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | cathie craigie cumbernauld and kilsyth |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | cathy peattie falkirk east lab |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | closure of jaeger campbeltown that |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | could we please clear up |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | deputy convener maureen macmillan highlands |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | dr sylvia jackson stirling lab |
| people do not trust the | snp | dr winnie ewing highlands and |
| members dorothy grace elder glasgow | snp | dr winnie ewing highlands and |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | dr winnie ewing oldest qualified |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | elaine thomson aberdeen north lab |
| con elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| lab elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| con elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| con elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| con elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | ewing dr winnie highlands and |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | ferguson patricia glasgow maryhill lab |
| dr winnie highlands and islands | snp | fergusson alex south of scotland |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | george lyon argyll and bute |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| grahame christine south of scotland | snp | hamilton mr duncan highlands and |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | i thank all concerned for |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | i thank david mundell this |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | i thank irene oldfather for |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | i thank you presiding officer |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | i will begin by doing |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | if the consortium which includes |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | ik ben heel tevreden dat |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | in recent days the minister |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | is the minister aware of |
| shona robison north east scotland | snp | mary scanlon highlands and islands |
| malcolm chisholm nicola sturgeon glasgow | snp | mary scanlon highlands and islands |
| shona robison north east scotland | snp | mary scanlon highlands and islands |
| irene mcgugan north east scotland | snp | maureen macmillan highlands and islands |
| colin campbell west of scotland | snp | maureen macmillan highlands and islands |
| fiona mcleod west of scotland | snp | maureen macmillan highlands and islands |
| fiona mcleod west of scotland | snp | maureen macmillan highlands and islands |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | maureen macmillan highlands and islands |
| richard lochhead north east scotland | snp | mr jamie mcgrigor highlands and |
| lab mr kenneth gibson glasgow | snp | mr jamie mcgrigor highlands and |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | on positive alternatives is the |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | phil gallie south of scotland |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | rhoda grant highlands and islands |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| robison shona north east scotland | snp | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | that does not make any |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | the deputy minister for highlands |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | to ask the first minister |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| duncan hamilton highlands and islands | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| winnie ewing highlands and islands | snp | will the member give way |
| morgan galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | committee members alex fergusson south |
| morgan galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | i thank the minister for |
| morgan galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | i wonder whether i may |
| morgan galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | john scott ayr con attended |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | morgan alasdair galloway and upper |
| neil galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | morrison alasdair angus western isles |
| morgan galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | mr jamie stone caithness sutherland |
| morgan galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | mr kenneth macintosh eastwood lab |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | muldoon bristow livingston lab mulligan |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | mundell david south of scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | mundell david south of scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | mundell david south of scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | mundell david south of scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | mundell david south of scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | mundell david south of scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | mundell david south of scotland |
| morgan galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | recovery of crew of fishing |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| alasdair galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| morgan galloway and upper nithsdale | snp | the fsa has said twice |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | alex johnstone north east scotland |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | angus mackay edinburgh south lab |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | as john young says a |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | ben wallace north east scotland |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | des mcnulty clydebank and milngavie |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | did the minister s discussions |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | do i have five minutes |
| for elder dorothy grace glasgow | snp | gallie phil south of scotland |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | george lyon argyll and bute |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | given that the executive has |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | hugh henry business motion motion |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | hugh henry crime international co |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | i am not sure how |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | i second that we should |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | i seek clarification on part |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | i send my best wishes |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | i thank the first minister |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | i thank the minister for |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | i want to return to |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | i wanted to follow on |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | i will ask a couple |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | irene is right to draw |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | it has been a very |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | it is something to look |
| adam hamilton south of scotland | snp | j jackson sylvia stirling lab |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | johnstone alex north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | johnstone alex north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | johnstone alex north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | lochhead richard north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | lochhead richard north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | lochhead richard north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | lochhead richard north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | lochhead richard north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | lochhead richard north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | lochhead richard north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | lochhead richard north east scotland |
| mr adam south of scotland | snp | lochhead richard north east scotland |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | minister you emphasise the importance |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | mr jamie stone caithness sutherland |
| brian adam north east scotland | snp | mr tom mccabe hamilton south |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | mrs margaret smith edinburgh west |
| mcleod fiona west of scotland | snp | mundell david south of scotland |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | of course i share fully |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | on a point of order |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | on a point of order |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | on a point of order |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | pauline mcneill glasgow kelvin lab |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | robert brown glasgow ld the |
| robison shona north east scotland | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| robison shona north east scotland | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| robison shona north east scotland | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| robison shona north east scotland | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| robison shona north east scotland | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| robison shona north east scotland | snp | russell michael south of scotland |
| michael william south of scotland | snp | s salmond alexander elliot anderson |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | scott john ayr con sheridan |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | sheridan tommy glasgow ssp stevenson |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | sheridan tommy glasgow ssp stevenson |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | sheridan tommy glasgow ssp stevenson |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | sheridan tommy glasgow ssp sturgeon |
| russell michael south of scotland | snp | sheridan tommy glasgow ssp sturgeon |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | that was the off noise |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | the amendments are very interesting |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | the conservatives have only one |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | the deputy minister for finance |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | the situation that christine grahame |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | to ask the first minister |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| michael russell south of scotland | snp | to ask the scottish executive |
| christine grahame south of scotland | snp | well here we are again |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | why has the executive not |
| adam ingram south of scotland | snp | william mccormack dumfries welfare rights |
Top

